Star Trek

Really hard and often boring to watch. Most stories lack a clear goal or motivation. Things just happen. At the same time its full of overacting and empty dialogue. Let me explain what I mean by comparing a Star Trek episode with a similar episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation. In episode S01E03 of the original Star Trek named "Where No Man Has Gone Before", the Enterprise happens to leave the galaxy and while flying through a nebula one of the crewmen is bestowed with supernatural powers. Over the course of the episode he develops extremely high intelligence and psionic powers. The rest of the crew, unaffected, immediately assume that he will become dangerous. They discuss his changes while he remains in the medbay where he reads books at supernatural speed, hears the thoughts of everyone on the ship, develops telekinesis and becomes hostile towards the rest of the crew. But there is no motivation to this. He simply gets arrogant, forgets everything about feeling human connections, empathy and his duties. The crew distrusts and thinks about killing him almost immediately. That itself is portrayed as a shocking development. Then they decide to maroon him on the planet, where Kirk and him punch it out, as usual for ST:O, another crewman weakens him and Kirk kills him and that's it. There is almost no substance, almost nothing to remember this episode. Get intelligent, get evil, get punched in the face, die. Contrast this with a similar episode in Star Trek: The Next Generation, named "The Nth Degree". The basic premise is that the crewman Barclay whom we know to be very shy and awkward around people gains supernatural intelligence. We know this from previous episodes and its also highlighted in the beginning of this episode. Therefore, its fun to see how he changes to an intelligent and confident man who even charms Diana Troy. The crew is not immediately afraid of him and only gets hostile towards Barclay after he takes over the ship - it makes sense. His takeover happens because the Enterprise needs to solve a problem quickly and therefore he connects himself to and replaces the ship's computer in an emergency situation but then wants to stay connected, because his mind would not fit into his old brain anymore. Again, there is a motivation for this - it makes sense. So he stays connected and takes over the Enterprise and makes the Enterprise travel tens of thousands light years to a distant galaxy where the crew and we find out that his transformation was initiated by aliens who use this as a way to explore other races. They make other races come to them, because the aliens don't like to travel. Not the best motivation, but its a motivation. The viewer can follow along and it all makes sense in the frame of the world and normal human behavior. So after having watched ST:TNG it really stands out how most of the episodes of the original Star Trek are plain, boring, with overacted dialogues, with the obligatory fist fight and love interest of Kirk. I don't understand how anyone can like this show without a huge portion of nostalgia.